Competitor research
How to identify your competitors: four buckets and a rule for dropping names
Identify competitors from your own lost deals: sort every name into direct, adjacent, in-house and status quo, give each a priority, and drop the noise.
A useful competitor list has four buckets: the direct rivals named in your lost deals, the adjacent products that solve the same need a different way, the in-house build your buyer could commission, and the status quo they keep when they buy nothing. Start from your own loss notes, give every name a source and a monitoring priority, and write down the rule that removes a name later.
Start from your own lost deals
Direct competitors are the companies your buyers chose instead of you. The evidence is in your CRM loss reasons, deal notes and the last few "we went with" emails, so read those before you search the web. Count which names appear across recent losses. If the list comes out long, check whether two segments have been mixed together; a startup deal and an enterprise deal rarely lose to the same vendor.
Paste the notes into Claude and ask for every company or alternative a buyer named, how often it appears, and the phrase the buyer used. Check that each name traces back to a specific note. A company Claude adds from general knowledge, with no note behind it, goes in the adjacent bucket as a hypothesis until a deal or a source confirms it. Remove what your company does not allow in an AI tool first; the rule for what to paste covers it.
With no loss notes yet, ask three sellers which names come up on calls. Their answers are hypotheses until deals confirm them.
Ask what else solves the need
Adjacent competitors do the same underlying job with a different kind of product. Find them from the buyer's need, not your product category. A team that buys competitive-intelligence software could also buy a media-monitoring tool, a research subscription or an analyst's time; each takes budget from your deal without appearing in a "competitive intelligence" search.
Turn on web search in Claude for this step. Anthropic's web search help article says Claude cites the sources it pulls from a search and that Team and Enterprise owners must enable the feature first. Describe the job your buyer named, ask for substitutes with a source for each, then open the sources yourself. A name with no deal note and no source is still a guess.
Most guides stop at two buckets. Dovetail's direct-competition guide and Determ's direct-and-indirect-competitors post define direct and indirect competition and list ways to find each; neither treats building in-house or doing nothing as a competitor. Both belong on the list.
Add the in-house build and the status quo
"We will build it ourselves" is a competitor with an engineering estimate attached. "We will keep the spreadsheet" is a competitor with no purchase order. Both take deals from you and neither shows up in a category search, so name them and write down what each looks like for your product: the internal tool a buyer's team already maintains, the shared document that does the job badly, the decision to wait a year.
The Japanese site hone.jp's guide to indirect competition splits indirect competition three ways: non-consumption (無消費), existing habit (既存習慣), where one example is paper and Excel in manufacturing, and replacement from another category. The status-quo bucket here merges the first two. The in-house build gets its own bucket because a deal lost to "we will build it" needs a different answer from a deal lost to a spreadsheet. Claude cannot supply either entry from a web search; they come from your sellers and your lost deals.
A worked example: the list for our own category
Here is the four-bucket list for competitive-intelligence software, the category Steve sells in, with the public evidence behind each placement.
| Bucket | Names | Evidence that puts them here | Priority |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct | Klue, Crayon | Both are Leaders in Gartner's first Magic Quadrant for Competitive and Market Intelligence Platforms, by their own announcements. In our September check of AI answers, ChatGPT named Klue in all eight answers and Crayon in seven. | Track closely |
| Direct | Kompyte, Contify | Named in five and four of the same eight answers. Semrush has owned Kompyte since March 2022, and Adobe has owned Semrush since April 2026, which puts Kompyte inside a larger marketing suite. | Watch occasionally |
| Adjacent | AlphaSense, media-monitoring tools, page watchers such as Visualping | Research subscriptions and alert tools that answer part of the same need. Bing's AI answer for "competitive intelligence platform" listed AlphaSense and Visualping beside the CI vendors. | Watch occasionally |
| In-house | A PMM's Claude Project plus free page watchers | Any CI buyer can build this; the competitor monitoring guide shows the one-hour version. | Track the objection |
| Status quo | Battlecards in a slide deck that nobody updates | The default for a team with no CI owner. Expect an objection like "our reps already have cards." | Track the objection |
| Dropped | Similarweb, Semrush (the SEO suite), Ahrefs | Bing's AI answers listed them under "competitive intelligence software", but they measure web traffic and search, not sales-ready competitor intelligence. | Dropped, with the date and reason |
The dropped row is the one most lists skip. Answer engines and listicles lump SEO suites into competitive intelligence, and a PMM who copies those lists ends up watching companies no buyer weighs against them. Writing the reason down stops the same name coming back from the next listicle.
Give every name a priority and a rule for dropping it
Give each name one of three priorities: track closely, watch occasionally or drop. Ask Claude to propose a priority and a one-line reason per company from the notes and sources you gathered, then decide yourself. Claude sorts candidates and surfaces categories you had missed; you own the list.
The dropping rule is a review, not a feeling. Once a quarter, check each name against recent lost deals, buyer conversations and sourced product changes. If none still justifies watching it, its owner moves it to the dropped section with the review date and reason.
Before a name goes on the tracked list, it passes every line below.
- The name appears in at least one lost deal, seller call or sourced search result, and the source is written next to it.
- It sits in exactly one bucket, with a one-line reason.
- It has a priority: track closely, watch occasionally or drop.
- Someone owns the next check, with a date.
Save the list where the next job starts
Save the finished list as one dated file in the Claude Project you use for product marketing, next to one file per competitor, so later work starts from the same roster. Chat memory is not a substitute for that file: a file has a date and an owner, and memory has neither.
From here, the competitor monitoring guide runs a weekly loop on the track-closely names, and the competitor research plan scopes the questions to answer about any one of them. A list kept by hand works while its owner can reopen every source on schedule; missed checks and stale entries are the signal that collection needs help.
Where Steve fits
Steve watches the companies on your list. Add a competitor's website and Steve checks it daily, flags pricing, product and messaging changes, and reads competitor news every day. On deals, Steve suggests the competitor and you approve, so the direct bucket fills from your pipeline instead of from memory.
The tradeoff is that Steve tracks companies with websites. The in-house build and the status quo have no pages to watch, so those two buckets stay in your own file. Load only the track-closely names into Steve; see the Competitive Intel product page.
Frequently asked
How do I identify my competitors?
Read your recent lost deals first and list every alternative a buyer chose. Then add products that solve the same need a different way, the in-house build your buyer could commission, and the status quo of doing nothing. Give each name a source, a bucket and a priority.
How many competitors should be on the list?
Three to five direct names plus a few adjacent ones for a mid-market B2B product. The real limit is upkeep: if nobody can say when a name was last checked, the list is too long.
Is doing nothing really a competitor?
Yes. A buyer who keeps a spreadsheet or delays the decision has chosen an alternative to you. Put the status quo on the list as a named entry with the objection that comes with it, so battlecards and messaging can answer it.
Can Claude find my competitors for me?
Partly. With web search on, Claude proposes adjacent candidates with citations and sorts the names in loss notes you paste. It cannot see deals you have not given it, so confirm every name against a deal record or a source you opened.
When should a competitor come off the list?
When no recent lost deal, buyer conversation or sourced product change justifies watching it, and its owner agrees. Move it to a dropped section with the date and reason, so it is not re-added later without new evidence.
Keep reading
All posts- October 14, 2026Competitor monitoring: what to watch, how to prove a change, and a weekly digest your team acts onHow to monitor competitors: which pages and sources to watch, how to prove a page changed, a full sample digest, and a one-hour weekly routine.
- September 14, 2026How to do competitor research: a one-page plan, an evidence table and a rule for disagreeing sourcesHow to do competitor research: write a one-page plan, log each fact in an evidence table, and settle disagreeing sources by scope, authority, then date.
- October 7, 2026What ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity say about you vs your top competitor: a ten-prompt auditRun ten fixed prompts three times each on four AI engines, memory off and region set, then report how often you are named and which pages shaped the answer.
- October 7, 2026Klue alternatives in 2026: who each tool is for, and when to stay with KlueStay with Klue for a curated, seller-facing programme; switch only for a stated reason. Five tools on 15 capabilities, with dated sources and switching costs.
Keep the names that earn it in front of your team